As promised here is the vanilla limoncello ice cream, so creamy I had to add it to the title. Did you shiver just a little? Is the idea of ice cream not appealing anymore now that spiced apples and pears invade your thoughts? Let me disagree here, and tell you that ice cream should be eaten year round, but lest we begin a gracious argument over food, I made chocolate cookies especially for you, with an ingredient that I’m afraid will never leave my kitchen again: brown butter.
That pound cake with figs ruined regular looking butter for me; I’m serious, you should’ve seen me brown a pound of it, and let it solidify again to use like regular butter, in everything.
I didn’t add it to the ice cream by a hair. Just kidding.
I didn’t add it to the ice cream by a hair. Just kidding.
This no-egg ice cream was long overdue since reading that this guy praised the chocolate one, a comment weighing more than a melon necklace in my kitchen since I consider his ice cream recipes to be one of the best. I had Jenni’s book in my hand a year and a half ago, while in DC, but put it down and bought another one instead, or should we say many others, because I never come back with less than five or six new cookbooks, except for the time when I brought home a dozen, and that was just in my carry-on. Well, cookbook issues aside, this is a splendid ice cream indeed, just like the title of the book promises.
Oh, and I finally bought it last week.
.
I was torn between the salted caramel recipe and using the vanilla limoncello and creating an ice cream that would remind me of sgroppino, the coolest way I know to drink vodka and eat ice cream at the same time, and hands down, one of the easiest ways to get me wasted.
In this case I failed to achieve that – it needs way more vodka, no vanilla and probably a few tries with a recipe, but rest assured that this coming summer, if there’s a lemon it will be made into sgroppino ice cream – but I got a lemon variation so subtle and sweet, it’s a good thing the booze is not pronounced, because I tend to grab a spoon every day and eat some. It’s no surprise it’s more lemons and cream than limoncello, because as I told you in my last post, the vanilla bean mellowed the liquor out, a characteristic that comes through in the final ice cream.
Growing up my favorite ice cream was the lemon chocolate ‘pine tree’, which meant a water-based lemon ice cream drowned in melted chocolate, so when it hardened it resembled a pine tree. Just like this one. It was the ultimate way to eat ice cream back then.
The cookies are a chocolate tart dough made into cookies, similar to shortbread, crunchy and chocolaty, with a hard to point aftertaste of smoky vanilla-flavored chocolate. Use it for tarts, it’s sensational. It was my first idea, because it is, after all, a chocolate tart dough, but then I just wanted to try it as is, to see if the brown butter was worth it. What?
Crazy, I know. When is brown butter not worth it?

Crazy, I know. When is brown butter not worth it?
barely adapted from Jeni’s Splendid Ice Cream, by Jeni Breton
Description
This dough is very crumbly, much like scone dough, but it should come together. When rolling it and cutting the cookies, do so in batches if necessary.
Ingredients
- ½ cup unsalted butter (browned and refrigerated until solid again)
- ½ cup + 1 Tbs confectioners’ sugar
- 1 large egg yolk
- ¾ teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1 ¼ cup all purpose flour
- 2 tablespoons to ¼ cup unsweetened cocoa powder (depending on how bitter you like it)
Instructions
- In the bowl of a food processor, blend butter pieces, sugar, egg yolk and vanilla until just mixed.
- Add flour and cocoa and blend until it starts to come together. Don’t over mix.
- Form into a disk, transfer to a plastic bag, and chill for at least 1 hour or up to 3 days.
- Preheat oven to 350ºF
- On a lightly floured surface, roll dough to ¼ inch thick and cut with a cookie cutter of your choice.
- Transfer to a baking pan and bake for 15 minutes, until dry. Cool completely on wire rack and store in an airtight container.
from The Last Course, by Claudia Fleming
.
Lovely recipe and beautiful cups! I’ve got similar ones (a gift from 10y ago), but recently broke 1 :’( I would like to buy a few new ones. Do you remember where you got yours from?
Hi Lia! I've had them for years and bought them in Buenos Aires, where I live. So I doubt it will be of any help, lol! But they're imported from China and are sold all over the world and with many different patterns. You'll probably find them online. I think they are sake cups, or maybe tea cups.
can the ice cream base be kept in the fridge overnight before being churned?
Hi Anisha! Yes you can keep it in the fridge. I find it's more convenient when I'm not churning the ice cream right away.
Hi,
I just mixed up the Brown Butter Cookie and the dough was real dry....ended up using all of one egg and the yolk from a second....should I panic now? The dough is in the fridge and I will roll them out later...has the consistency of clay right now....
Don't panic! It's a crumbly dough, and that makes for crunchy cookies. Did the dough come together before you put it in the fridge? It should. When you're ready to roll it, fold it over itself a couple of times until it's malleable. But it IS a crumbly dough, you'll probably end up rolling it in batches. Let me know how it goes, please!
Paula, there are so many wonderful things going on in this post, I don't know where to start! First of all, your photos are like art. I want to enlarge all of these and plaster them all over my wall so that I can drool all the time. Fabulous idea on making the tart dough into cookies. I wish I could buy as many cook books as my heart desires! One day I'll own a house and just devote an entire room to them. Sigh...this post was just what I needed today after a long stressful work day. Reading your lovely, witty words and admiring the incredible things you make recharges my soul.
it sounds delish!
these are the kind of cookies I love breaking my paleo eating for.
no problem!