Shortbread is a glorious mix of butter, sugar, and flour, creating a melt-in-your-mouth cookie. I added lemon, and it became even better, with a nice zing cutting through that buttery amazingness. The dough can be refrigerated for a day before baking, and the baked shortbread keeps very well. A great holiday gift idea.
I love shortbread. It's so easy to make and so difficult to screw up!
Adding citrus zest makes it stand out.
There's a nice acidity that cuts through all that butter and sugar in the best way. We can certainly agree that shortbread is a rich cookie.
- Simple ingredients.
- Easy to make: the dough is patted onto the pan, so it's easier to make than shortbread lemon cookies that must be cut and glazed individually.
- Make ahead: you can make the dough a day ahead, pat it in the pan, cover it and refrigerate it until ready to bake. After it's baked, it keeps well in an airtight container, a metal tin preferably.
- Serving it: it can be used to accompany ice cream, to serve with after-dinner coffee, or simply as part of a dessert table with other more sophisticated recipes.
This recipe today uses powdered sugar for the dough and a small amount of granulated sugar for sprinkling the shortbread before baking; it creates a crunchy crust and a nice, golden color.
This recipe is a twist on the traditional one and a cousin to these fabulous buttery lemon shortbread cookies we love so much.
Readers Reviews
Absolutely divine! We opted to leave off the granulated sugar and then used fresh lemon juice mixed with powdered sugar to make a glaze, as suggested. It's so lemony and tart and perfect!
- Suzette
Great recipe—so good it’s hard to share! I added a few drops of lemon extract to enhance the lemon flavor even more. It's so easy and delicious! Thanks for sharing!
- Joan
I made this for the Fort Campbell culinary team as a dessert for one of our important meals. I used it as a crust. Needless to say, the crust was the best part.
- Dantia
Adding extra lemon flavor
This lemon shortbread recipe uses a lot of butter and sugar, making it challenging to make the lemon flavor stand out. You can choose whether you like a hint of citrus or a brighter lemon flavor.
- Lemons: I love to use a lot of fresh lemon zest, and occasionally add fresh lemon juice. The latter can slightly change the texture as it's a liquid, so don't add too much.
- Lemon sugar: you can work the lemon zest into the sugar at the beginning, before adding it to the butter. The peel will start to release its natural oils and impregnate the sugar, adding an extra punch of tart lemon flavor.
- Lemon extract or emulsion can quickly and easily enhance the lemon flavor. I use pure ones like Nielsen Massey's pure lemon extract or Mc Cormick's culinary pure lemon extract. You can also use artificially flavored ones that you know are good, like Frontier lemon flavor.
- Paste and emulsion: these are thicker than extracts and concentrate a lot of flavor. I love and regularly use vanilla paste but have never tried a citrus alternative. But I heard good things from both Nielsen Massey's Pure lemon paste and LorAnn lemon emulsion.
Ingredient list
- Unsalted butter: use the best brand you can afford - the better the butter the better the flavor.
- Powdered sugar: also called confectioners' sugar or icing sugar.
- All-purpose flour.
- Salt.
- Lemon zest: freshly grated from fresh lemons to get the best lemon flavor. I use a microplane zester/grater directly over the shortbread dough.
- Granulated white sugar.
- Vanilla extract.
Steps to make lemon shortbread
No need for an electric mixer. You only need a spatula or hand whisk.
Butter must be at room temperature (soft but not greasy or beginning to melt), and you should be able to mix everything with a spatula. If using extra flavorings, this is when you add them together with the lemon peel.
It can look like you won't be able to incorporate all the dry ingredients, but you will. With a flat rubber spatula, you can fold and scrape the mixture until the flour integrates fully.
Trust the process, and in a few minutes, you'll have a soft, easy-to-manage dough.
Patting the dough: the best way to fill the pan is to distribute pieces of dough throughout the bottom. That way, when you spread it, it will be better leveled. If you dump it all in the middle and start to pat it with your fingers, it will be harder to reach the edges.
Crunchy topping
Shortbread will get a crisp top if it's golden brown.
In this version, we supercharge that step by sprinkling a tablespoon or two of sugar before baking. It will stay put (not seep into the dough) and add a nice crunch.
This is optional but highly recommended. You can use brown sugar for a more caramel crunch.
Baking and cutting
When is it fully baked?
This is a great question, as it usually has people going for either the barely colored shortbread or the golden finish. Just like with cookies, it depends on personal taste. Do you like softer, lighter cookies, or go for the crisper, colored ones?
I alternate between both but tend to like a crispier, golden-colored shortbread.
Scoring and cutting
This part is essential, and you must do it while the shortbread is still hot, about ten minutes after you take it out of the oven.
Using a smooth-bladed knife, cut strips lengthwise and then do the same to the other side, creating a criss-cross pattern (image below).
Alternatively, cut squares or triangles (cut squares in half diagonally).
Shortbread is very rich so smaller pieces are usually better.
I find that it's better a few days after it's baked because the flavors are more balanced. You have to store them in a tightly closed tin (ideally) so that they don't lose their crunchiness.
We do it to prevent the butter from melting before the shortbread is baked. A cold dough will bake better and not be tough, which is crucial to getting that buttery, crunchy bite.
Yes, you can. Either the unbaked dough already in the pan or the baked cookies or fingers. This last option I recommend doing so after cutting and separating the pieces. And always remember to wrap the pan or the cookies well to avoid as much freezer burn and ice as you can.
In an airtight tin, it can last a week or two. This will depend on how it was baked. Slow, even baking produces crunchier shortbread that is drier so it lasts longer.
Kitchen Notes
- Organization: read the recipe first and ensure you have ingredients at the correct temperature, utensils and equipment needed, and enough workspace. This will make the process so much easier.
- Baking time: consider that all ovens and pans are different, even if they look similar. The baking time in my recipes is as accurate as possible, but it might take you more or less time. You can use a thermometer(like the OXO oven thermometer) to check that your oven is at the right temperature. I recommend keeping track of how your oven works and what tiny details you might need to adjust.
- Is the resting period needed? You can bake it directly, but the refrigeration time makes for a more tender, melt-in-your-mouth shortbread. I think it's worth the wait, but you should adjust recipes to your timeline and palate.
- Storing: it keeps well for a week or more after you cut it, so it's great for gift-giving. Always use an airtight container, ideally a metal one or a jar.
Holiday ideas with this recipe
It all comes down to different flavorings and toppings. Make a large batch, double (or triple?) this recipe. If using a stand mixer, mi with the paddle attachment at low speed.
Flavorings: divide the dough and add different flavorings to each portion, in addition to the lemon. Add another citrus, a ground spice (like cardamom that goes very well with lemon), or ground nuts.
Different shapes: I cut them into sticks but can be cut into triangles, squares, or diamonds.
Toppings: drizzle them with a simple lemon glaze made with powdered sugar and lemon juice (similar to the one we use for the Lemon Shortbread Cookies) or a thin chocolate ganache. Before the glaze sets, you can sprinkle citrus zest, ground nuts, or festive sprinkles.
Gifting: layer the dry ingredients in an airtight jar, attach a nice card with the instructions to make the shortbread, and give them out as gifts during the holiday season.
Related recipes you might like:
Let me know in the comments below if you made this recipe and loved it and if you had issues so we can troubleshoot together. I love to hear what you think, always. Thanks for being here. It's much appreciated.
You might also consider subscribing to our FREE email series 'Baking the Best' and our regular newsletter. Or connect via Facebook, Instagram, and Pinterest.
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Read my disclosure policy.
Lemon Shortbread (buttery and easy)
Click the stars to Rate this Recipe!
Ingredients
- ¾ cup unsalted butter, at room temperature
- 1 ¼ cups all-purpose flour, or cake flour
- pinch of salt
- 2 tablespoons lemon zest, see Notes below for extra lemon flavor
- ⅛ teaspoon vanilla extract, drops, literally
- ½ cup powdered sugar, sifted
- 1 tablespoon granulated sugar, for topping
Instructions
- Have ready a 9-inch (20x20cm) square baking pan that has been buttered or sprayed with baking spray.
- Line it with parchment paper: take a large piece of parchment paper of about 8 inches (almost as wide as the pan) and cover the bottom and two sides of the pan. The other two sides will remain buttered but not lined with paper. This will help you remove the shortbread after it's baked.
- In a large bowl, mix ¾ cup unsalted butter with 2 tablespoons lemon zest (I zest it directly over the butter mixture using a microplane zester) and ⅛ teaspoon vanilla extract.
- Add ½ cup powdered sugar and incorporate well so there are no lumps. I recommend sifting the sugar before adding it, or sifting it directly over the butter mixture as I do.
- Add 1 ¼ cups all-purpose flour and pinch of salt in 2 parts, mixing with the spatula until it is smooth, well combined and no dry spots remain.
- Transfer the dough to the prepared pan, scattering small amounts on the bottom.
- Lightly pat the dough with your hand until it covers the whole surface. Make sure the edges are covered. Make it as even as possible, but relax because it will not be completely smooth.
- Refrigerate the whole pan, covered in plastic wrap, for at least 1 hour (and up to 24 hours). You can bake it directly, but this resting time creates a more tender shortbread, in my experience.
- Preheat the oven to 325°F (160°C).
- Sprinkle 1 tablespoon granulated sugar over the top before baking.
- Bake the shortbread for 40-45 minutes, until the top is dry, has puffed slightly and is beginning to color. You can leave it a few more minutes for a more golden shortbread. Just don’t let it dry out.
- Let cool for 10 minutes on a wire rack and carefully cut into sticks, squares or triangles with a smooth-bladed knife.
- Let cool on the cooling rack completely, lift the whole square of the pan with the aid of the parchment paper, and carefully break each piece.
- Keep in airtight cookie jars or tins.
Notes
Diane M. says
So easy and delicious. I made some to glaze and some plain. Both excellent. I used Plugra butter and the cookies are melt-in-your-mouth rich and luscious. My pan was golden brown after 30 minutes, so I recommend watching carefully. A definite keeper!
Paula Montenegro says
Happy to know they worked so well Diane!
Sonya says
If I want to double it should I use two separate pans or use 9x13? Thanks
Paula Montenegro says
Yes Sonya, it's the best way. Use two pans. Happy baking!
Bobbie Zimkowski says
This is one of my favorite recipes. I have added a dusting of lavender into the powder sugar. Yummy.
Lisa says
Delicious! Followed recipe- came out perfect.
Suzette Saxton says
Absolutely divine! We opted to leave off The granulated sugar, and then used fresh lemon juice mixed with powdered sugar to make a glaze as suggested. So lemony and tart and perfect!
Paula Montenegro says
SO happy to know you loved them Suzette! I agree that the glaze is an amazing addition. Have a great week.
liz says
mine were absolutely delicious. I put a teaspoon of vanilla paste. One thing was they crumbled a lot. Is there any way I can make them more firm? am i doing something wrong?
Paula Montenegro says
Hi Liz! Happy that you liked them. Crumbling is usually due to too much dry ingredients. You can try adding a little less flour. Ingredients are all different and sometimes butter can have more water content or flour be measured differently. The dough should be easily patted in the pan.
Melissa says
Great Recipe - steps were really easy to follow. My dough came out sticky and soft - I was wondering if that’s normal? I ended up adding extra flour to help it come together.
I used a cookie mould with this recipe - Dough kept getting stuck. I was wondering if anyone else had the same problem?
Paula Montenegro says
Hi Melissa, it's not a recipe for rolling and cutting, it doesn't have enough flour, that's why I pat it and score it only. Have a good weekend!
Laurie Waller says
I’ve used this recipe a couple of times. Can’t remember how long I baked them but they were delicious.
Your recipe says bake for 40-45 minutes, but at the top of the recipe it says prep time 45 minutes and cook time 20 minutes ???
Paula Montenegro says
Hi Laurie! The baking time is 40-45 minutes. I adjusted the prep time to include the resting time also. Hope this helps. Have a great holiday week!
Dantia Rios says
I made this for the fort Campbell culinary team as a dessert for one of our important meals I used it as a crust for a apple peach cobbler with vanilla caramel almond gelato and sugar cookies as part of my crumble. Needless to say the crust was the best part
Paula Montenegro says
That's SO great to hear Dantia! I love the idea btw, to use it in a crumble. Thanks for letting me know, I appreciate it.
Sarah says
Really simple and easy to make shortbread and the results are gorgeous! I think the timings may be off a little though as mine were done by 35 mins (in fact a little over-golden) thankfully still tasted fantastic x
Paula Montenegro says
So happy to hear you liked them Sarah! Ovens are all so different, it's hard to specify sometimes and exact baking time. Have a great week!
Joan says
Great recipe, so good it’s hard to share! I baked in my 8” sq pan & for some reason they were done @ about 30 minutes. I did add a few drops of lemon extract to up the lemon flavor even more. So easy & delicious! Thanks for sharing!
Paula Montenegro says
So happy you liked them Joan! I like the idea of lemon extract. And ovens are all different and, in theory, all recipes have to be adjusted, even if slightly. That's why it's so important to know our own ovens. Have a great Sunday!
Pam S says
I haven’t made this yet, but I’ll bet this would make an awesome crust for lemon bars!
Paula Montenegro says
I bet it would be Pam!
Candice says
I already am a huge fan of shortbread... adding the lemon zest in this recipe creates such a great flavor. I don't think I can ever go back to regular shortbread!
Amanda says
Oh, I love the lemon addition to these shortbread cookies! These will be perfect for all the cookie baking I have planned this week. Thanks for sharing!
Marisa Stewart says
Shortbread is absolutely the best and I love your addition of lemon to it. Lemon flavor is my favorite and this recipe has given me the inspiration to make one more batch of treats to share when our guests come over. Can't wait to make it.
Leslie says
I have a friend who REALLY loves lemon shortbread! This is a great idea to make for her for the Holidays...she will love it!
Cathleen @ A Taste of Madness says
I love shortbread, but I have never tried lemon shortbread before!! I NEED to give this a go sometime 🙂
Tammy says
Shortbread is my weakness and these look so light and crisp...that bit of lemon is perfection. A delightful recipe that can be enjoyed year round!
Aleta says
I LOVE shortbread and am crazy about anything lemon. I can’t wait to combine the two and make these treats for Christmas! Thanks for sharing 🙂
Eva says
Great idea to add the lemon zest. I love shortbread but some find it too much. The tang of the lemon zest sure helps making the rich buttery taste more palatable to those who do not love it. I personally do, but I think I'll love it even with lemon!
Sharon says
I love lemon based desserts and this shortbread recipe. A great way to brighten up the gloomy days.