I put together our favorite recipes and tips to take to a holiday potluck party or to plan one if you want to host a more relaxed Christmas gathering. It allows everyone to contribute their favorite dishes, making your holiday dinner a collaborative masterpiece. This post is updated every year with relevant content.

A potluck is not just about sharing the workload; it's about sharing the joy of good food and company.
So, let's dive into some simple yet scrumptious potluck Christmas recipes that will make your feast unforgettable.
A few things to keep in mind and to let your guests know.
Types of dishes or courses to include
It depends on the size of the gathering, the attendees' preferences, and the event's overall structure. Here are some general guidelines to help you decide.
- Consider the potluck size: For larger parties, include a variety of dishes to cater to different tastes. This could include main dishes, sides, salads, and desserts. For smaller gatherings, you might focus on a well-rounded main course and a couple of complementary sides.
- Keep it manageable: while variety is great, it's also important not to overwhelm yourself. Choose a manageable number of dishes you can prepare and transport without stress if the event is not at your house.
- Include a main dish: a substantial one, whether turkey, ham, a vegetarian option, or another protein, is a must. This forms the meal's centerpiece and provides a filling option for all guests.
- Balance side dishes, salads, appetizers and bread basket: although they're all different courses, they can be used interchangeably. For example, a pumpkin muffin might be a bread or side dish option. So, think of them as one large section or course.
- Is kitchen space limited for reheating? Is there enough space in the fridge for dishes that require chilling? Ask about the available kitchen facilities and equipment. Knowing whether there's limited oven, stove or fridge space can influence your choice of dish, helping you opt for something that won't cause logistical challenges.
- Is there a preference for finger food or will utensils be used? Knowing whether guests will be standing and mingling or sitting at a table can influence your choice of dish. This is also a consideration if hosting the party and considering the utensils, glasses and plates needed to cater to everyone in more than one course.
How many servings should each dish yield?
Consider the final number of people expected, but explain to contributors that not all dishes have to serve all, as there will be other options. If everyone brought a dish large enough to serve everyone, there would be far too much food. Otherwise, you'll be left with an enormous amount of leftovers that won't fit in the fridge and freeze. Trust me on this one.
How to calculate servings of each dish?
- Know the guest count: determine the approximate number of guests attending the potluck. This is the starting point for determining serving sizes.
- Consider dish type: different dishes have varying serving sizes. Main dishes and protein-centric options generally require larger servings than sides or desserts. Aim for about ½ to ¾ pounds of food per person for main courses. Side dishes and desserts typically range from ¼ to ⅓ pound per person.
- Factor in dish variety: You can adjust portion sizes slightly, as people will likely sample multiple items. If it's a smaller gathering with fewer dish options, you might want to provide slightly larger servings.
- Consider side dish ratios: Aim to provide a variety to accommodate different tastes. If there are three or more side dishes, you can plan for smaller portions. You might want to increase the portion size if there are fewer sides. You might also want to include different dishes around the same ingredients, like a sweet potato casserole and candied sweet potatoes. People will probably have one or the other, not both, so you can combine the number of guests, counting both as one.
- Adjust for appetizers and desserts: if your potluck includes them, these can often be smaller portions since they are part of a larger array of options. For desserts, consider that guests might want to sample more than one.
- Drinks: When feeding a large party, consider using a glass drink dispenser or punch bowls to serve drinks, especially fruity drinks like punch and sangria that can be made ahead.

Check for dietary considerations
If you're aware of specific dietary considerations (e.g., vegetarian, gluten-free), consider these preferences when planning your dish. There should be one for each course: side dish, appetizer, dessert, and appetizers if included.
Factor in kids
If children will be attending the potluck, consider their smaller appetites. You may need to adjust portions accordingly. And have some very basic dishes for picky eaters, including a simple dessert guaranteed to appeal to them.
Communicate with other contributors
If possible, talk with others that are bringing dishes to ensure a diverse spread and avoid duplication. This can also help in planning quantities more accurately. And come up with a plan for leftovers: Will they stay at the host's house, or will participants take doggy bags home?
Use a serving size chart
Online serving size charts can provide general guidelines for various dishes. They consider the type of dish and the number of guests. They're especially good for large gatherings, where it's hard to calculate if you've never hosted a potluck or the host does not calculate servings and just lets contributors take whatever they want.
Our favorite Christmas potluck recipes
There is a wide array of recipes for this type of gathering.
For smaller parties, you can make a leg of lamb or glazed ham and a few average-sized desserts, like a chocolate torte and a classic pavlova.
For larger ones, casseroles, brownies and bars (like cheesecake for a crowd and fudge) will be easier to manage and feed a crowd.
Homemade Eggnog
It's traditionally made with rum or brandy, but you can make it without alcohol. And adjust the amount of spices and sweetness to your liking.
Cranberry Sangria
This sparkling cranberry sangria takes 10 minutes to prepare and lasts hours. It can be served cold or warm.
Caramelized Onion Dip
A great dip with a creamy texture and rich flavor, it's an easy appetizer made with caramelized onions and sour cream.
Pomegranate Salad
This festive green salad with fresh pomegranate seeds, fruit and nuts is ready in 20 minutes.
Sweet Potato Casserole
An old-fashioned sweet side dish with a creamy sweet potato filling and a crunchy top. It's quick and easy to assemble.
Slow-roasted Lamb
A fantastic holiday centerpiece and is much easier to make than you might think. It's flavorful, moist, and served with gravy.
Apple Cider Sangria
This is a favorite fall cocktail with warm flavors, white wine, apple cider and fruit. It's fantastic for a holiday party.
Apple Walnut Salad
A simple holiday salad with walnuts that is ready in 20 minutes and has a quick, tangy apple dressing.
Pumpkin Cran Muffins
Moist and easy to make, these pumpkin muffins are spiced and soft, with a tangy bite from the cranberries. They keep well and can be frozen.
Panettone Bread
This Italian bread has a unique flavor and texture. It's a sweet dough with nuts and raisins.
Italian Pandoro Bread
A plain golden bread with a wonderful flavor and texture. It's enriched with eggs and butter, so you know it'll be delicious.
Date Nut Bread
A wonderful loaf cake, fragrant, sweet and old-fashioned with dates, walnuts, brown sugar and browned butter.
White Vanilla Fudge
A homemade white chocolate treat with an extra dose of vanilla flavor. It's easy to make and creamy.
Cran Pistachio Fudge
With only 4 ingredients, this is the easiest white fudge, made in the microwave or the stovetop! It is a simple recipe that comes together quickly and lasts for weeks.
Sour Cream Cookies
Great soft sugar cookies that are tender but keep their shape if you want to decorate them! The dough is easy to work with and perfect to make with kids.
Snowball Cookies
Melt-in-your-mouth butter cookies with ground almonds. Also known as almond powdered sugar cookies, they are a holiday classic and perfect for gifting.
Vanilla Creme Cookies
Sweet and buttery, with an extra dose of vanilla flavor. The dough and filling can be made ahead.
Gingerbread Cookies
Sweet and spiced holiday ginger cookies with a simple icing. The dough can be made ahead and baked thin, crisp, or chewy.
Linzer Cookies
Shortbread-like almond cookies with a raspberry jam center. The cookies can be made in advance.
Chocolate Snowballs
These chocolate almond cookies have a melt-in-your-mouth feel that makes them irresistible.
Milk Chip Cookies
This milk chocolate chip cookie recipe is a twist on your favorite cookie. Use chips or milk chocolate chunks, like we do.
Chocolate Mint Cookies
Chewy chocolate peppermint cookies that are perfect for the holidays. With candy cane bits and lots of chocolate flavor.
Dulce de Leche Cookies
These are sweet, shortbread-style alfajores. Two buttery cookies filled with gooey dulce de leche.
Classic Whoopie Pies
A cross between a cake and a soft cookie, these chocolate whoopies are amazing, intense and sweet.
Chocolate Torte
A rich and showstopping dessert served with berries and cream. It has almonds, is flourless and cuts like a dream.
Pear Frangipane Tart
Prepare to be captivated by this delectable pear frangipane tart. A layer of almond cream cushions slices of pears in a sweet shortcrust pastry.
Best Pavlova
A popular dessert for special occasions and celebrations, it consists of a meringue base with a crisp exterior and a marshmallow-like center.
Brown Sugar Cheesecake
Creamy, smooth, with a sour cream topping and the unmistakable caramel flavor that only brown sugar can achieve. It keeps well and can be frozen.
Linzer Tart Recipe
This is a wonderfully spiced almond pastry filled with an enhanced raspberry jam. It's simple and delicious. The dough and baked tart can be made ahead and frozen.
Gingerbread Loaf
If you love that unique gingerbread flavor, this is a recipe you can't miss. The crumb is moist and tight but soft with sweet glaze and a perfect mix of spices.
White Coconut Truffles
These truffles are incredibly easy to make and delicious! Full of white chocolate, ground nuts, and a hint of rum.
Red Velvet Cake Pops
Made with red velvet cake and a white chocolate coating, they can be festive if you use sprinkles and colored icing.
Peppermint Brownies
Intense and fudgy brownies with mint, cream cheese frosting and crushed peppermint candies.
Hazelnut Brownies
This is an easy recipe for fudgy brownies with hazelnuts that are incredibly rich. And they happen to be gluten-free.
Raspberry Cheesecake Brownies
Fudgy brownies studded with raspberries and a cheesecake swirl. An irresistible flavor combination.
For more ideas, check the whole Christmas recipe archive.
Let me know
If you made this recipe and loved it, you can comment below and leave a five-star ⭐️ review. Also, if you had issues, let me know so we can troubleshoot together. I appreciate honest feedback and suggestions.
You can also subscribe to our FREE email series 'Baking the Best' and our regular newsletter. Or follow and save my recipes on Pinterest.
Rate and review this recipe